News and commentary on Religion, especially Southern religion.

Showing posts with label Religion | Baptist Faith and Message 2000. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Religion | Baptist Faith and Message 2000. Show all posts

Friday, February 26, 2010

The online demise of The Council for Biblical Manhood and Womanhood

The Council for Biblical Manhood and Womanhood Web site is back. They explain their long absence as follows:

Approximately three weeks ago, it appears that someone hacked into our server and severely damaged the CBMW website. Not only did this prohibit use of the site but is also kept us from even being able to send out a mass email to even explain the challenge we were facing to some of you.

We have been working around the clock to fix the problem. In addition to this, we moved our entire site to a different server that will give us access to more technical help in the future and will save us quite a bit of money as well. I am deeply grateful for the people who helped us rectify the situation and enable us to once again serve you with material that will help your home and church.

Not persuasive reasons for an extended outage, unless you stir in large helpings of other management issues. Whatever the case, they did not fulfill Wade Burleson's wish [explained below].

The Council for Biblical Manhood and Womanhood (CBMW) is as of this writing missing from the Web and Internet at large. The domain name has apparently not been lost to them, but it isn't attached to a server.

They lent their fundamentally Southern Baptist clout to the Danvers Statement on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, which was subsequently affirmed as a key document of faith by Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary and by Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary.

Wade Burleson today says in his comment on the CBMW's perhaps temporary Internet invisibility:

Over the course of the past three years I have written a few times about The Council for Biblical Manhood and Womanhood (CBMW). Southern Baptists, including Dorothy Patterson, Al Mohler, Danny Akin and others, serve on the Board of Directors of the Council. Randy Stinson, Dean of Church Ministries at Southern Seminary, serves as the Executive Director of the CBMW. I have written about CBMW teaching various forms of patriarchy, calling Irving Bible Church elders' decision to allow a woman to teach the Bible "a grave moral concern" (comparable to homosexuality), advocating the eternal subordination of women to men, encouraging abused women to merely "pray for their husbands," and stating that opposing "male authority" is the same as opposing Christ's authority.

He proposes that CBMW return as a site of "scholarly exegesis."

Rather than, say, continue as a living caricature of Christian paternalism.

Monday, November 9, 2009

Southern Baptist Convention seppuku

Adoption of the Baptist Faith & Message 2000 sent thousands out the Southern Baptist Convention door and pushed a still larger number back a step or two while institutions which could, continued to flee the conservatives.

Weighing the spoiling fruits of their labors, SBC fundamentalist power brokers adopted another self-destructive strategy, as Enid, Oklahoma, pastor Wade Burleson explains:

So conservative leadership decided to change, behind the scenes, the doctrinal statements that served as the standard for cooperation and service within individual SBC agencies. These changes in the doctrinal statements of SBC entities were approved and implemented without SBC convention-wide approval. Designated trustees began changing the doctrinal statements to reflect the core of organized Fundamentalism (anti-spiritual gifts, Landmark, pre-millenial, etc.). There is nothing necessarily morally wrong with Fundamentalism if the adherents to that particular ideology love those who disagree with them. The problem with Fundamentalism, especially in the Southern Baptist Convention, is when people of cooperation become more interested in doctrinal conformity than missional cooperation. When that happens, Baptist people, pastors and churches who used to identify with the cooperative efforts of Southern Baptists will CEASE cooperating.

With overarching demographic change running against them, their secrecy-blighted Great Commission Resurgence floundering as the chickens of their earlier secrecy come home to roost, the SBC power brokers seem incapable of adapting.

Saturday, October 31, 2009

Building 'biblical' fortresses in friendly-fire battles

When Christian groups argue — and some seen to thrive on the process — advantage goes to the side which claims the "biblical" high ground. If they can hold it.

Take for example this statement by Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, whose president, Paige Patterson, is a well-known veteran of the Southern Baptist controversy:

While the Baptist Faith and Message 2000 is the only confessional document at Southwestern, the seminary also affirms the Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy and the Danvers Statement on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood. These statements clarify the seminary’s general posture on the the subjects of inerrancy and gender roles.

Several questions immediately come to mind.

If the Baptist Faith and Message 2000, is the school's "only" confessional statement, why the other two statements?

The school says the other statements "clarify the seminary's general posture" on inerrancy and gender roles.

The general posture?

What does that mean?

And why does it need clarifying?

If the other two statements are needed to "clarify" the school's stance, then why not add them as confessional statements?

Or else, why isn't the only confessional statement enough?

Yet the confessional statement is not enough, at least not enough for Southwestern seminary.

Turns out, it isn't enough for Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary in North Carolina either.

Tony Cartledge reported that Southeastern is making even the ministers who supervise students in practical ministry efforts sign all three statements, along with the school's Abstract of Principles.

Cartledge is correct to say that seminaries have the right to draw their own lines of participation "as narrowly and fearfully as they want to." But as he points out, such moves "exclude a number of capable, qualified, experienced ministers from the program, to the great detriment of their students."

Cartledge says the Danvers statement "was adopted in 1987 by the 'Council on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood,' which consists largely of people with close connections to Southern Baptist Theological Seminary." The document, he said, "attempts a response to the perceived danger of 'feminist egalitarianism' by affirming a belief that husbands should be the final authority in their homes (albeit humbly), and that wives should submit to their husbands."

A closer look at the statement raises even more questions.

For example, item number seven of the statement's affirmations includes the phrase, "In all of life Christ is the supreme authority and guide for men and women ... ." Yet, in all the biblical texts given in support all 10 items, not a one is from the gospels, the section of the Bible where the life of Christ and his teachings are highlighted.

The eighth item of the statement insists that in "both men and women a heartfelt sense of call to ministry should never be used to set aside Biblical criteria for particular ministries." Instead, the statement says, "Biblical teaching should remain the authority for testing our subjective discernment of God's will."

And in this instance, the schools get to decide the criteria used to override those calls, and it is the seminarys' teaching that becomes authoritative.

The seminaries thereby complete construction of a "biblical" facade around their interpretation of particular passages.

Sunday, February 1, 2009

Comes the Southern Baptist Inquisition

Moves toward disfellowship of First Baptist Church, Decatur, Ga., for calling a woman (Julie Pennington-Russell) as senior pastor have become the prevailing measure of the Southern Baptist Convention's (SBC) descent to inquisitorial enforcement of the 2000 Baptist Faith and Message (BF&M).

The historic SBC tenet "We have no creed but the Bible" is dead, mourned Texas pastor Ken Coffee on Jan. 28. FBC Decatur's prospective disfellowship and other actions mark the rise of the SBC's BF&M 2000 to the status of creed. Coffee outlines the history of the BF&M 2000 inquisition, observing by way of pointed introduction:

Now, it should be noted here that Texas Baptists as a convention (BGCT) have never adopted the 2000 BF&M. Texas still uses the 1963 version, which some have called the finest such document ever written. One wonders why the SBC has not kicked the BGCT out for not adolpting the 2000 BF&M. Could it have anything to do with money?

Even absent attack on an entire association, current enforcement of the theologically flawed BF&M 2000 as creed is "absurd," and could tear apart what remains of the SBC, warns Oklahoma pastor Wade Burleson.

Burleson wrote:

The FORCED acceptance of the BFM 2000, by threatening to "disfellowship" from those churches who don't agree with every single one of its tenets, is patently absurd. Those who push "disfellowship" from churches that disagree with a portion of the BFM 2000 will destroy our convention if they are allowed to succeed. The SBC will have to eventually disfellowship from over 25,000 Southern Baptist churches. That is the number of SBC churches, at least according to one seminary professor, that have expressed disagreement with the BFM 2000 in either church practice or church doctrine in areas other than women pastors.

Burleson identifies "closed communion" as a BF&M 2000 doctrine with which "most Southern Baptist churches and pastors disagree." And throws down the gauntlet on that issue himself. For on that and other issues, he refuses to join those who have have "elevated a creed above the Bible!"

Lost amid the confused enforcement of BF&M 2000 as a creed, Ms. Pennington-Russell wrote in her Jan. 23 newsletter to her congregation, is the fundamental purpose of the church:

May God save us from the deadly notion that this church exists to provide goods and services for eligible "members." If anything, the witness of Scripture shows us that the church exists for the sake of the world. e exist to worship God and invest ourselves in bringing Christ's kingdom on earth. We esit to discern and to do God's will in an ever-changing world. We exist to follow Jesus into gospel adventures of all kinds in collaboration with all of God's people, whatever their denominational preferences or doctrinal stances.

There is no bedrock Baptist justification for the distraction from core church mission by BF&M "bullying," Burleson argues. It is "ungodly, unbaptistic and ridiculous" and "must stop." And stopping it, as with stopping bullies on a school playground, is a matter of confronting the bullies. In this case, a matter of confronting the bullies with the truth.

For as Coffee explains, "the BF&M was intended to be nothing more than a guide to churches to help them understand whether or not they wanted to be included in the fellowship of churches we call the denomination. It was never intended as a document for excluding churches. No church that would say they disagree with most points of the BF&M would want to cooperate with the denomination."