News and commentary on Religion, especially Southern religion.

Showing posts with label holocaust denial. Show all posts
Showing posts with label holocaust denial. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 23, 2009

SSPX discussions on a years-long path

Begun with an explosion of controversy over the de-excommunication of holocaust denying SSPX Bishop Richard Willamson and three others, the discussions toward reconciliation of Rome and SSPX are proceeding with laborious care.

Jesuit journalist Austen Ivereigh writes:

The "conversations" follow a systematic method. First, the topic. Then, the SSPX sends a paper laying out its doubts. The Vatican representatives answer in writing. Then both sides meet to discuss the exchanges.

The meetings will be filmed and recorded by both sides, which may indicate a healthy mutual scepticism but will make for fascinating material for future historians. The conclusions of each discussion are then taken to the Pope and the Superior General of the SSPX.

The frequency of the meetings will depend on whether the topic is a new one or has already been discussed: if the first, the conversations will take place about every three months; if the second, every two. The next meeting is scheduled for mid January.

He estimates three years will be required just to cover topics currently known to be on the table and laments that the recorded proceedings are not being posted for general enlightment on YouTube.

Indeed. Could a pope who has become more Internet-aware as a part of this process not be persuaded to do exactly that?

Monday, September 21, 2009

Bishop Williamson/SSPX bursts back into flame

"The Vatican was warned about the Holocaust-denying views of SSPX Bishop Richard Willamson before it lifted his excommunication," wrote Damian Thompson today. And the world is going to hear all about it. Wednesday night Sveriges Television AB will broadcast “an attack on the Holy Father" which covers what the Vatican knew about Williamson prior to the move toward rapprochement with Society of St. Pius X.

According to Carlos Antonio Palad, the promotion for the almost inevitably explosive program says:

Last winter the Catholic Church was shaken by the interview made by Uppdrag granskning with Bishop Richard Williamson. The Pope and the cardinals in charge assured the world that they had not known about the interview, but this is not true.
Swedish Bishop Arborelius: "From our side we passed the information on. That is so to say the usual way of doing it, the local church passes important news about the Church on to the papal representation.”
What did the Vatican know about the Holocaust-denying bishop?

None of this is going to leave the until recently somewhat reassured international Jewish community or not altogether mollified U.S. Bishops awash with good cheer. Nor will it smooth launch of the first round of discussions between the representatives of the Holy See and SSPX.

Exercising his gift for wry understatement, Thompson writes:

Anyway, now that Rorate Caeli has drawn attention to the documentary, you can rest assured that the Pope’s enemies and critics will get to work again. I’ll be interested to see what The Times [of London] makes of it. One request: this time, could the Vatican press office get its act together?

Answer [not from the Vatican]: Probably not.

Sunday, February 15, 2009

Pope casts Austrian Catholicism into crisis [Update: Wagner withdraws]

Controversial pastor Gerhard Maria Wagner said Sunday he will ask the pope to rescind the promotion to auxiliary bishop in Linz, Austria's third largest city.

The Associated Press reported:

"Regarding the fierce criticism, I am in prayer and, after consulting the diocesan bishop, I have decided to ask the Holy Father in Rome to take back my promotion as auxiliary bishop," Wagner said in a statement released by Linz Diocesan Bishop Ludwig Schwarz.

More is expected to be disclosed at the meeting Monday, detailed below.


Pope Benedict XVI's de-excommunication of a Holocaust-denying priest and appointment of an ultra-conservative to bishop in Linz have together set off a crisis in Austrian Catholicism that bishops are meeting in emergency session Monday to address.

The controversial appointee, Gerhard Maria Wagner, has condemned the Harry Potter books as satanic, said homosexuality was curable and ruled out lay participation in Church affairs. After the Hurricane Katrina disaster in 2005, he commented: "It's no coincidence that in New Orleans all five abortion clinics as well as night clubs were destroyed."

Together the appointment of Wagner and the de-excommunication of Richard Williamson sent an "appalling" signal from the Vatican, commented Erhard Busek, a Roman Catholic who served as Austria's vice chancellor between 1991 and 1995. A signal that the pope is either remarkably careless, or else intends to impose the most conservative kind of orthodoxy on the church. Unless, as Neil Schoenherr at the University of Chicago suggested, "underreported strokes suffered by the Pope in 1991 and 2003" are affecting his judgment.

The crisis includes and extends beyond the clergy. Notably:

  • Reuters reports that "Four times as many Catholics have officially quit the Church in Linz so far this year as in early 2008, the Austrian Press Agency APA reported, and departures have also been running higher than usual in Vienna, Salzburg, Tyrol and Lower Austria."
  • The liberal lay Catholic movement We Are Church urged Austrians not to contribute money to the church and announced it would set up "solidarity accounts" for contributions to be held "until the situation improves."
  • Franz Wild, chief church dean (senior priest) of Upper Austria province and pastor in the town of Traun, told the Associated Press that 31 out of 35 Upper Austrian church deans present during an informal meeting late Tuesday voted for a declaration of no confidence in Wagner.
  • The conservative governor of Linz, Josef Pueringer, hit out at Wagner's nomination, saying it conveyed "the wrong image" of the church.

Crisis comes against the background of the Catholic Church in Austria whose clerical rigidity was driving church membership down when two "high-profile sex scandals in 1995 and 2004 turned that outflow into a veritable haemorrhage." Austria was 91% Catholic when World War II began. Now:

In the past 15 years, more than 370,000 people have quit the church, 40,500 in 2008 alone, bringing the number of believers down to 5.58 million or 66 percent of the population as a whole.

Vienna's current archbishop, Christoph Schoenborn, who called Monday's meeting, has labored to remedy the problem. Only to see the pope's twin controversial decisions unraveling all he has woven together.

Prominent Roman Catholic theologian Paul Zulehner told AFP, the church appears to be in "self destruct" mode, and "The gap between believers and the bishops will continue to widen." An Austrian church which has already lost its liberal membership, is in danger of losing its center, and Monday's crisis meeting can in itself not reverse that.

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Legionaires in calculated denial, not reform

Legionaries of Christ

Legionaires face no intervention from the Vatican, CathNews reports. An official from the Congregation for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life told Catholic News Agency that it is "too early" to tell if the Legion of Christ leadership can work through the issue.

Besides, the Vatican is too busy with controversy over holocaust-denying Bishop Williamson - one of the four schismatic bishops whose excommunication was lifted by the pope.

John Desmond, a well-regarded and widely-published Catholic journalist, reports that the Legionaries carefully timed their admission of the sexually predatory behavior of founder Fr Marcial Maciel:

My contacts assert that the convergence of these two big news events--the outrage prompted by the Bishop Willliamson affair, followed shortly afterwards by the new revelations regarding Father Maciel's "double life" -- was no accident: the order's superiors and their ecclesial allies took advantage of the crisis surrounding Bishop Williamson to minimize the impact of the new disclosures regarding Maciel. The Mexican superiors, I'm told, believe the present tempest will blow over and the Legion will pull itself together and go on as before.

If that strategy works Maciel accomplices will not be detected.

The transparency called for by Fr. Thomas Berg in his letter to the associated lay group, Regnum Christi, will not come to pass.

Instead there will be, and there already is, denial.

Denial reported by the American Papist who attended a Mass celebrated last Sunday in this country, a Mass led by the head of the Legionaries of Christ, Fr Alvaro Corcuera. Attended by members of Regnum Christi, the lay group associated with the Legion of Christ, that Mass Fr Corcuera said:

On the topic of abuse, Fr Alvaro said that he does not have any specific access to information, and one cannot know what is true and isn't (here, and at other points I will note, the exact content of his meaning wasn't always clear - I was listening very carefully for what would be admitted, etc., but coming away it's still hazy to me exactly what was said. Things were said, but often not in a definitive way.)

We agree with Damian Thompson, who wrote in his blog Holy Smoke in The Telegraph, "I don't believe that."

The same Mass concluded with a prayer which included the words:

Since the Legion and the Movement will be vigorous and will flourish as long as the spirit of our founder is present and active in our lives and behavior, we ask you to open our eyes to the urgency of learning, assimilating and passing on the doctrine, spirit, apostolic methods, genuine traditions, discipline and lifestyle of the Legion and Regnum Christi, just as our founder has made them known to us, since this is our responsibility.

Maciel's history of predation and cult leadership inevitably shaped the order's culture. An outside investigation is required. Fr. Thomas Berg was right when he wrote to Regnum Christi members:

Finally, I encourage you to speak to Legionary leadership, and even in the form of petition letters, demand nothing less than full transparency regarding the case of Fr. Maciel.

Demand that [Legionaries General Director] Fr. Alvaro seek an independent third party investigation (perhaps in the form of a temporary review board or Visitation team from the Holy See) into uncovering any Legionaries who may have been accomplices to Maciel.

Demand that a similar body guide Legionary leadership in introducing any needed reforms into the internal culture, methods and religious discipline of the Legion.

Tuesday, February 3, 2009

U.S. Bishops demand a high standard for full reconciliation

The price of full reconciliation of the four disastrously un-excommunicated, right-wing Catholic Bishops?

A full-throated end to their anti-Semitism and holocaust denial, demanded the The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops on Tuesday.

Cardinal Francis E. George of Chicago, the president of the group, also "called the statements by Bishop Richard Williamson 'deeply offensive and utterly false' and called the outrage from Jews and Catholics 'understandable.'"

Specifically about full reconciliation, reported the Boston Globe, George said:

The Holy Father's lifting of the excommunications is but a first step toward receiving these four bishops, and the priests who serve under them, back into full communion with the Catholic Church. If these bishops are to exercise their ministry as true teachers and pastors of the Catholic Church, they, like all Catholic bishops, will have to give their assent to all that the Church professes, including the teachings of the Second Vatican Council.

Mention of the Second Vatican Council is important here. because it resulted in the church's renunciation of anti-Semitism and led to a historic warming of relations between Catholics and Jews.

Until Tuesday the U.S. Catholic bishops were largely silent on the matter, thus provoking criticism.

Now, they are apparently pushing back against any real or perceived Vatican impulse to give the bishops of the Society of Saint Pius X any but the most exacting path to full reconciliation.

Pushing back is what service of their church requires, given the pope's refusal to invest more heavily in quieting the waters he has whipped into an unrelenting storm.