News and commentary on Religion, especially Southern religion.

Showing posts with label network neutrality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label network neutrality. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

Net Neutrality is important to people of faith

Three years ago Casting Light warned that Net Neutrality matters to the SBC. Because, if assured, Network Neutrality means network access providers must treat all data equally, without preferential restrictions.

Indeed, Net Neutrality matters to all people of faith, as Jeffrey Rosen illustrated in his keystone example at The New Republic this week:

You might think that a decision to block the King James Bible would violate the First Amendment, or at least raise important constitutional concerns. But, if Comcast, a private company, is blocking a particular technology, rather than discriminating against particular speakers, there’s no state action and no obvious peg for a First Amendment lawsuit. That’s why the FCC is crucial to shaping the future of free speech. (Disclosure: I have known [Chairman of the Federal Communications Commission Julius] Genachowski since we clerked together years ago for a federal judge.) Under the proposed FCC net-neutrality principles, broadband operators like Comcast can’t "discriminate against particular Internet content or applications" and will have to be transparent about their network-management practices.

Although Network Neutrality is the official policy of the Obama Administration, the battle over the details is intense.

Major service providers seek control over the "last mile of the Internet" to their customers so that they can "manage" traffic to enhance profits from their own service offerings. And there is a war over what Net Neutrality will mean for wireless services, with providers predictably seeking exemptions.

As a result, your freedom of digital expression is still at risk.

Casting Light offered examples of oppressive Internet provider practices in 2006, and the list has grown. Rosen offered several, and Comcast blockage of access to the King James Bible was in fact one of them.

He wrote:

Two years ago, Comcast, America’s second-largest high-speed Internet provider, blocked BitTorrent, a popular peer-to-peer file-sharing application that could be used to distribute (among many other things) high-definition TV video that would compete with Comcast’s video services. The obstruction was discovered by an amateur singer who wanted to share public domain performances of barbershop quartets with his fellow aficionados. After initially denying that it was blocking BitTorrent, Comcast, which was literally denying access to the King James Bible, claimed that it wasn’t blocking the file-sharing application, but merely delaying it to conserve bandwidth as part of "reasonable network management."

As with health reform, the debate is awash with misinformation. FreePress deals with the worst myths and helps elucidate the fundamental issues.

Where do you stand?

Monday, September 21, 2009

Net neutrality and religion

Religious Right blog storms and evangelical online social networking could come unpredictably and irrevocably to nothing if network neutrality died, and under the eight-year reign of the Bush administration, network neutrality was dying.

This morning Federal Communications Commission chief Julius Genachowski in a speech at the Brookings Institution said the FCC must be a "smart cop on the beat,” preserving Net Neutrality against increased efforts by providers to block services and applications over both wired and wireless connections.

It is in effect a fight for freedom of the 21st Century press, one in which we are all invited to participate, as he explained:

We have witnessed certain broadband providers unilaterally block access to VoIP applications (phone calls delivered over data networks) and implement technical measures that degrade the performance of peer-to-peer software distributing lawful content. We have even seen at least one service provider deny users access to political content.

It is and should be largely invisible that the underlying network architecture of the Internet makes possible ready access to all manner of online publishing.

As long as and only as long as the principles of network neutrality re sustained.

You can have sustained 21st Century freedom of online speech and press, if you can keep it in the face of the armies of loggyists deployed at a cost of millions of dollars in an attempt to eliminate network neutrality.

The FCC invites your participation in the process of shaping and sustaining network neutrality at http://www.openinternet.gov/.