News and commentary on Religion, especially Southern religion.

Friday, February 27, 2009

Church-blogging ain't beanbag

Aggressively blog a church's policies and governance, and the deacons may adopt a resolution directed at you and see it approved in a vote by the congregation [video].

Some approve of the action at First Baptist Church of Jacksonville, Fla.

Some do not and defend the anonymously penned FBC Jax Watchdog blog, which is the target of the resolution.

FBC Jacksonville attracted considerable attention by sponsoring blog posts calling Catholicism a cult [eventually removed from the site]. Although the grievances of Watchdog certainly neither began nor ended there.

The bylaws governing resolution of grievances within that church appear to be heavily loaded against dissent.

Whatever the merits of any particular issue there, that repressive approach tends to drive debate underground -- often into anonymous blogs -- not eliminate it.

Addendum

William Thornton notes that FBC Jacksonville conducted a "public flogging of a former member" without, of course, "naming names." He goes on to say the disciplinary process sounds "less Biblical than it does medieval." [Amen to that.]

No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for commenting. Comments are moderated. Yours will be reviewed soon.